A Systems Design project at DTU, team of 4

Keeping first-time investors invested through a market fall

A concept inside Groww's Mutual Funds section that helps first-time SIP investors decide calmly when the market falls.

My part
Personas, the high-fidelity prototype, 2 of the 6 usability tests and the final deck
Note
A class concept. Not made for or with Groww.
A stone bear walking in front of a falling red stock chart, with the app's fund dashboard, a past falls card and a saved goal note in front of it.

01The problem

Many young Indians start a SIP and stop it during their first big market fall.

They lock in the loss and miss the recovery.

48%of SIPs opened in 2023 were closed within a year, according to NISM.
BeforeToday
  1. Tap 1Pause SIP
  2. Tap 2A generic question
  3. SIP paused

In today's apps, pausing a SIP takes two taps. There is no context, a generic question and no reminder of why the investor started.

AfterOur flow
  1. Tap 1Cancel reason
  2. One screenMatching help
  3. Tap 2Pause SIPor Cancel SIP anyway

Groww's cancel reasons stay, and each reason opens at most one screen of matching help. Cancelling still takes two taps.

02My part

This was a team project.

This was a team project of 4. My teammates led the desk research. Everyone proposed investor archetypes, and I turned them into the final personas the team worked from.

Once the team chose the problem, I built the high-fidelity prototype, ran 2 of the 6 usability tests, changed the design based on what my testers showed, and made the final presentation.

Led by me

  • Final personas
  • High-fidelity prototype
  • Final presentation

Shared

Desk research
Teammates
Investor archetypes
Everyone
Usability tests
2 of the 6 by me

03Seeing it as a system

We mapped retail investing in India as a system of investors, platforms, regulators and advisers.

We found three places where investors get hurt.

01

Start

Some open an account and never start.

Conflict with the system: Medium

02Chosen

Stay

Some start a SIP and stop at the first fall.

Conflict with the system: Low

03

Trade

Some young traders lose money in futures and options.

Conflict with the system: High

We chose the second one, which we called Stay. Helping the investor here hurts no one else in the system, and it happens at one clear moment, the first market fall.

Slide: every investing decision sits inside a system. The investor sits in the middle of six steps, from research to monitor and review. Around them are eight outside forces, such as regulators, technology and personal context, each marked with the steps where it matters most

04Research

Research

We compared 7 Indian platforms and 7 international ones on how they handle SIP onboarding, nudges, trust and the moment a user wants to stop.

  1. 01

    Every Indian platform shows a list of reasons at cancel.

  2. 02

    None of them helps the user based on that reason.

  3. 03

    In India, only registered advisers may give investment advice.

    So the app cannot tell anyone to keep investing or which fund to pick. It also has to avoid dark patterns.

Compared: Groww, Zerodha, Fyers, Dhan, Upstox, Angel One, INDmoney, Vanguard, Fidelity, Betterment, Wealthfront, Hargreaves Lansdown, Scalable Capital, Raiz.

The key insight was simple.

Investors usually have the right information, but not at the moment they decide. The gap is timing and placement, not knowledge.

Slide: the fear loop. The market falls, only red numbers show on screen, fear and family pressure build, the SIP is stopped at a low point, and the loss becomes real

05The design

Fit into the existing system. Don't add a new layer.

Calm moment, starting a SIP

  1. Fund pageChanged
  2. Start SIPChanged
  3. Dip planNew
  4. SIP startedChanged

Moment of fear, a market fall

  1. DashboardChanged
  2. SIP detailsChanged
  3. Skip sheetChanged
  4. Cancel reasonChanged
  5. Matching helpNew
  6. EndingExisting

One switch in Settings turns it all off, and Groww works exactly as before.

01

Prepare while calm.

When starting a SIP, the investor can write a note to their future self and choose when to be reminded, from a 10% to a 30% fall.

The fund page also shows the fund's worst past fall.

Plan for a market fall: a note the investor writes while calm, and a slider to be reminded at a fall of 10% to 30%
Dip plan
Fund page for a small cap fund, showing its worst fall in a bad year before the investor starts a SIP
Fund page
02

Explain the fall without advising.

On a fall day, the dashboard shows a calm card with how far prices fell and how past falls recovered.

It never says buy or sell.

Mutual funds dashboard on a fall day with a market update card: how far small caps fell and how long past falls took to recover
Dashboard on a fall day
03

Slow the decision without blocking it.

Groww's cancel reasons stay, and each reason opens at most one screen of matching help.

Cancelling still takes two taps.

Choose your reason to cancel this SIP, a list of six reasons including can't invest for a few months and fund is too risky for me
Cancel reason
04

Give the right help for the right reason.

If the fund feels too risky, the investor can move future SIPs to a fund lower on the SEBI riskometer, sorted A to Z, without the app picking one.

Before you cancel: small cap funds swing a lot, with options to move future SIPs to a lower risk fund, keep this fund, or pause
Fund too risky
Lower risk funds, sorted A to Z, each with its level on the SEBI riskometer and no fund picked by the app
Lower-risk funds

The reason decides the help.

Each reason opens at most one screen of matching help.

Cancel reason
  1. Can't invest
    Can't invest right now: the investor's own note, then ways to keep the SIP going, such as pausing, skipping one instalment or lowering the amount
    Ways to keep your SIP going
  2. Not satisfied with returns
    Before you cancel: this fall compared with past falls in small caps and how long each took to come back
    This fall vs past falls
  3. Fund too risky
    Before you cancel: small cap funds swing a lot, with an option to move future SIPs to a lower risk fund
    Small cap funds swing a lot
  4. Pause
    Pause sheet: pause instead of cancelling, for 1, 2, 3 or 6 months, with cancel SIP anyway below
    Pause instead of cancelling?

Ideas we rejected

A 24-hour cooling-off timer

Feels like a trap

An adviser call

Counts as advice

"Buy the dip" alerts

Counts as advice

Auto-switching funds

Counts as advice

06Testing

We tested the prototype with 6 people aged 22 to 26, one at a time, thinking aloud.

I ran 2 of the tests myself.

The tasks

  1. 01Start a SIP
  2. 02Want to stop during a fall
  3. 03Need cash
  4. 04Turn the reminders off

Testers said the help came at the right moment and did not feel pushy. The past-falls comparison was the most useful part.

Some wording confused them, so I changed it.

Three wording changes after testing, before and after
BeforeAfter
"Want to withdraw money""Can't invest for a few months"
The note on every skipThe note now appears only from the 3rd skip in a row
The growth estimateWhat the investor will have put in
Skip sheet that shows the investor's own note, now only on the 3rd skip in a row

Skip sheet, with the note on the 3rd skip in a row

Slide: what testing changed. Each thing testers told us sits beside what we changed in response

07Limits

Six testers is a direction, not proof.

Limits

All six testers were people we knew.

We did not measure how many testers kept their SIP.

The numbers inside the prototype are illustrative.

How it was built

I built the prototype screens and the deck with Claude through Figma MCP, under my direction.

The research, the problem choice and the design decisions came from the team and me.